I've listened to the album over the past year now. It never gets old.
Every few full listens my favorite song would change. There's absolutely no flaws here. I think my overall favorite is May Queen, just from its position in the album and its unique mournful tone.
May Queen fits perfectly for an album that's almost done, and it's sad tone contrasts beautifully with the romp that is Call of the Coven. Into the Wild seems incredibly lighthearted by contrast, elevating it as well.